SAFT vs SIGI
As of Sep 20, 2026, Safety Insurance Group (SAFT) scores 8.0/10 and Selective Insurance Group (SIGI) 6.8/10 on AlphaStocks' five-model composite, so SAFT scores higher. SAFT trades 41% above its model fair value; SIGI trades 1% below its model fair value.
SAFT
SAFETY INSURANCE GROUP INC
8.0
Strong Buy
$103.57
SIGI
SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC
6.8
Consider Buy
$86.67
SAFT vs SIGI: Which is the Better Investment?
SAFETY INSURANCE GROUP INC (SAFT) scores 8.0/10 while SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC (SIGI) scores 6.8/10 on AlphaStocks' composite model. SAFETY INSURANCE GROUP INC has the higher composite rating of Strong Buy. On a P/E basis, SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC trades at 9.9x, making it the more attractively priced of the two. SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC trades further below its estimated fair value.
This comparison is algorithmically generated and is not financial advice.
| Metric | SAFT | SIGI |
|---|---|---|
| Scores & Fundamentals | ||
| Composite Score | 8.0/10▲ | 6.8/10 |
| Rating | Strong Buy▲ | Consider Buy |
| Price | $103.57 | $86.67 |
| P/E Ratio | 15.4 | 9.9▲ |
| ROE | 11.1% | 15.1%▲ |
| Market Cap | $2B | $5B |
| Fair Value | $73.23 | $87.80 |
| Dividend Yield | 4.6%▲ | 1.6% |
| Sector Rank | #8 of 265▲ | #59 of 265 |
| Model Verdicts | ||
| Piotroski | Strong | Strong |
| Buffett | Strong▲ | Attractive |
| Graham | Strong▲ | Attractive |
| Lynch | Limited Data | Limited Data |
| Greenblatt | Limited Data | Limited Data |
Related comparisons
SAFT vs SIGI: Which Stock Scores Higher?
SAFETY INSURANCE GROUP INC (SAFT) and SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC (SIGI) are both in the Financials sector. SAFT currently leads with a composite score of 8.0/10 (Strong Buy) compared to SIGI's 6.8/10 (Consider Buy).
The AlphaStocks composite score evaluates each stock across four dimensions: Quality (business strength measured by Piotroski F-Score and Buffett quality criteria), Value (discount to intrinsic worth using Graham, Lynch, and Greenblatt models), Momentum (6-month price trend), and Timing (a confirmation signal that requires both value and momentum to align). A higher composite score indicates stronger overall fundamentals combined with favorable market conditions.
This comparison uses the same scoring framework for both companies, ensuring an apples-to-apples evaluation. Scores are recalculated daily after market close using data from SEC filings and market prices. Read the full methodology to understand how each model contributes to the composite score.
Scores are algorithm-generated research tools, not investment recommendations. Past performance does not guarantee future results. Always do your own due diligence. Full disclaimer