AlphaStocks
6.0
Consider Buy

American Financial Group Inc (AFG)

As of Sep 19, 2026, American Financial Group Inc (AFG) scores 6.0/10 on AlphaStocks' five-model composite, #130 of 265 Financials stocks. At $142, AFG trades 35% above its model fair value of $105.

Financials / Multi-line Insurance

S&P MidCap 400

$142.30

Middle of the pack. No strong signal either way.

Consider Buy

Score based on 4 of 5 models — moderate confidence

Data as of Sep 19, 2026

#130out of 265 in Financials

Is AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC a Good Investment in 2026?

AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC (AFG) scores 6.0 out of 10 on AlphaStocks' composite model, earning a Consider Buy rating. The Piotroski model rates AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC as Attractive (6/8). The Graham model is the least favorable, rating it Attractive. AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC currently trades 35% above its estimated fair value of $105. AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC ranks #130 out of 265 stocks in the Financials sector.

This summary is algorithmically generated and is not financial advice.

Key Metrics

P/E14.1ROE17.6Market Cap12BDiv Yield5.1

Estimated Fair Value

$105.1335% above

Trading above estimated fair value. Eps growth of -5% may not justify the premium.

Model-based estimate, not a price target.

5-Model Analysis

Each model evaluates this stock from a different angle. Combined, they form the composite score above.

Piotroski

Attractive

6/8

Buffett

Attractive

Business quality & competitive moat

Graham

Attractive

88% above fair value

Lynch

Limited Data

PEG 1.1

Greenblatt

Limited Data

Earnings yield + return on capital

Frequently Asked Questions

Is AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC (AFG) a good investment?
As of Sep 19, 2026, American Financial Group Inc (AFG) scores 6.0/10 on AlphaStocks' five-model composite, #130 of 265 Financials stocks. At $142, AFG trades 35% above its model fair value of $105. That is a middle-of-the-pack score with no strong signal either way.
What is AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC's Piotroski F-Score?
AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC's Piotroski F-Score status is Attractive. The raw score is 6/8. The Piotroski F-Score evaluates financial health using 9 fundamental signals including profitability, leverage, and operating efficiency.
Is AFG overvalued or undervalued?
Based on AlphaStocks' model-based fair value estimate of $105, AFG appears overvalued. The stock currently trades 35% above its estimated fair value. Trading above estimated fair value. Eps growth of -5% may not justify the premium.
How does AFG compare to other Financials stocks?
AMERICAN FINANCIAL GROUP INC ranks #130 out of 265 stocks in the Financials sector, placing it in the top 49% of its sector by composite score. This is an above-average position relative to sector peers.
What do investment models say about AFG?
AlphaStocks evaluates AFG using five proven investment models. Piotroski: Attractive; Buffett: Attractive; Graham: Attractive. These models are combined into a single composite score of 6.0/10.

Similar Stocks

LNCGNWL

Compare AFG with

AFG vs LNCAFG vs GNWAFG vs LAFG vs TRV

Scores are algorithm-generated research tools, not investment recommendations. Past performance does not guarantee future results. Always do your own due diligence. Full disclaimer