Property & Casualty Insurance stocks ranked by AlphaStocks score

As of Nov 6, 2026, ACGL (7.5), SAFT (7.3) and CB (7.2) have the highest composite scores of the 22 scored Property & Casualty Insurance stocks; the industry median is 6.5.

Data as of Nov 6, 2026. The score describes how each stock measures up to five published methods and price momentum; it is not a forecast or a recommendation.

All 22 Property & Casualty Insurance stocks, by composite score

#	Ticker	Company	Score	Fair-value gap	P/E	Price
1	ACGL	Arch Capital Group Ltd.	7.5	45% below	9.4×	$110.60
2	SAFT	Safety Insurance Group Inc	7.3	71% above	22.1×	$104.29
3	CB	Chubb Ltd	7.2	1% below	13.0×	$371.69
4	TRV	Travelers Companies, Inc.	7.0	23% above	10.4×	$402.83
5	SIGI	Selective Insurance Group Inc	6.8	9% above	12.0×	$101.78
6	THG	Hanover Insurance Group, Inc.	6.8	70% above	11.9×	$249.03
7	ALL	Allstate Corp	6.5	1% above	6.9×	$266.89
8	CINF	Cincinnati Financial Corp	6.5	9% below	11.0×	$188.37
9	ORI	Old Republic International Corp	6.5	21% below	9.1×	$40.40
10	PGR	Progressive Corp	6.5	14% above	11.7×	$233.09
11	RDN	Radian Group Inc	6.5	52% below	9.2×	$37.26
12	WRB	W. R. Berkley Corp	6.5	4% above	16.2×	$76.98
13	EIG	Employers Holdings, Inc.	6.4	31% above	31.9×	$46.92
14	FAF	First American Financial Corp	6.2	7% above	9.6×	$68.19
15	RLI	RLI Corp	5.9	24% below	16.3×	$69.73
16	AGO	Assured Guaranty Ltd	5.7	26% below	9.2×	$71.66
17	MCY	Mercury General Corp	5.1	96% above	7.3×	$84.53
18	HCI	HCI Group, Inc.	5.0	16% below	7.0×	$191.25
19	UFCS	United Fire Group Inc	4.9	152% above	9.0×	$47.18
20	AMSF	Amerisafe Inc	4.8	45% below	9.5×	$20.36
21	HIG	Hartford Insurance Group, Inc.	4.2	18% below	8.7×	$137.10
22	STC	Stewart Information Services Corp	4.0	43% below	12.5×	$49.02

Models that do not apply to Property & Casualty Insurance stocks

Piotroski F-Score: not applicable to 22 of 22 — Piotroski's F-Score does not rate insurers: no current ratio, no gross margin, and float is leverage by design.
Lynch Categories and PEG: not applicable to 22 of 22 — Lynch's categories and PEG do not apply to banks and insurers
Greenblatt Magic Formula: not applicable to 22 of 22 — Greenblatt does not rate insurers

A model that does not apply is left out of the stock's score, never counted as a fail. See the methodology.